Zuty

blizz needs a few pple like you workin for em

Why TY

~Zuty

Reading blogs.
Frostbolt gun sounds OP, also, that many items should not have a proc. Look at the amount of items with procs now, incredibly low, and this instance would boost it almost one fold.

Originally Posted by McBankington

Reading blogs.
Frostbolt gun sounds OP, also, that many items should not have a proc. Look at the amount of items with procs now, incredibly low, and this instance would boost it almost one fold.

And what is wrong with CoH items?

Nothing is OP about a FB gun, it would be a low rank of FB, the slow would last 4 seconds, and it would not stack with Concussive Shot since one slow would overlap the other being that Concussive would slow an additional 10% more and for 1 more second. So if anything (and you would need to be lucky enough to not have CS on CD and for this to proc) you are slowed by 40% for 4 seconds and then at the last tick of that you are slowed by 50% for 5 seconds. The proc would not be so low you never see it, but not so high that it goes off ever other shot.

I still haven't given other stats on it, so the DPS could be lower then another gun. If anything this would just be a cheap trick gun for a class just using what is available to them.

~Zuty

i know this is very old but humor me, i was banned when you originally posted.
1. CoH effects that do AoE damage OR apply a DoT are FAIL. like bank said, they arent around anymore b/c they suck. it ruins CC effects for a marginal amount of damage; deff not worth it.
2. i hope there's more than a cloth set, eep! need more melee love.
3. having an extremely low drop chance item off each boss just seems 'tarded to me. make the last boss of the instance drop 1 extremely rarely. if you dont want to narrow it down to one piece, then set up a loot table between all the rare shit and have the last boss drop one out of the possible amount extremely rarely.
4. i loved all the little bios tho, that was a nice touch
5. some decent gear ideas but a lot of them seem gimmicky (CoH hit X, Y, Z, etc...def dont think there's nuff gear to cover all classes either, this seems tweaked in the favor of casters for sure)
6. make the bosses lvl 31 elites, trash lvl 29 elites (so its like a heroic dungeon - bosses +2, trash = lvl)
7. yea like i said idk if anyone will even read this, much less zuty himself. but i felt compelled to post b/c i wanted to back in the day but was banned. def gave this a lot of thought and it shows, but it could potentially be amazing with some more thought. pze.

Originally Posted by Falkor

i know this is very old but humor me, i was banned when you originally posted.

Banned from what now?

1. CoH effects that do AoE damage OR apply a DoT are FAIL. like bank said, they arent around anymore b/c they suck. it ruins CC effects for a marginal amount of damage; deff not worth it.

O R L Y

They may not exist in this bracket and they may be scarce, but it's no reason to ignore it. I'd rather use something unique then the same rehashed items over and over again.

2. i hope there's more than a cloth set, eep! need more melee love.

Of course.

3. having an extremely low drop chance item off each boss just seems 'tarded to me. make the last boss of the instance drop 1 extremely rarely. if you dont want to narrow it down to one piece, then set up a loot table between all the rare shit and have the last boss drop one out of the possible amount extremely rarely.

I don't really have the drop rate % in stone, I just don't want an epic to drop every time.

4. i loved all the little bios tho, that was a nice touch

Thank you.

5. some decent gear ideas but a lot of them seem gimmicky (CoH hit X, Y, Z, etc...def dont think there's nuff gear to cover all classes either, this seems tweaked in the favor of casters for sure)

More instances to be made. Like how WC has a leather DPS set, this instance has a Clothy set and caters to casters more while the other instances will focus on the other class roles.

6. make the bosses lvl 31 elites, trash lvl 29 elites (so its like a heroic dungeon - bosses +2, trash = lvl)

Yeah, it would be something like that. I am going to try this on my 49 server and scale everything up appropriately.

7. yea like i said idk if anyone will even read this, much less zuty himself. but i felt compelled to post b/c i wanted to back in the day but was banned. def gave this a lot of thought and it shows, but it could potentially be amazing with some more thought. pze.

Well thanks for commenting. I mostly posted it here in case I lost the original file (which did happen) and I like hearing feedback from people so I can get better at item/NPC creation.

~Zuty

Originally Posted by Zuty

Banned from what now?

from the site lol. for almost a month.

Originally Posted by Zuty

O R L Y

you proved my point though, those are allll from preBC, they dont make em anymore (or rarely) b/c they realized they break CC for marginal procs =P. being unique is cool, but at the same time...look at stuff like bloodrazor that people dont use b/c a bleed proc.

Originally Posted by Zuty

Well thanks for commenting. I mostly posted it here in case I lost the original file (which did happen) and I like hearing feedback from people so I can get better at item/NPC creation.

yup just tossin in my two cents. gl makin it

Originally Posted by Falkor

you proved my point though, those are allll from preBC, they dont make em anymore (or rarely) b/c they realized they break CC for marginal procs =P. being unique is cool, but at the same time...look at stuff like bloodrazor that people dont use b/c a bleed proc.

Again, I don't want to rehash old ideas for weapons. We shouldn't just look towards the future, we need to revisit the past and while an AoE proc will break CC it's something different that was never revisted again after Vanilla WoW.

I'd at least like to try it out.

~Zuty

nothin wrong with experimenting. just saying blizz tried it once and obviously something made them reconsider. i guarantee if you offer a comparable weapon w/o the aoe proc it will be used instead (ex. thrash blade vs. bloodrazor).
and no offense but you contradict yourself by saying you dont want to rehash old ideas, yet you should revisit the past. sometimes things are just left alone b/c blizz actually knows what they're doing (for once). im sure they realized it was a gimmicky proc idea with more negatives than positives.
however you are free to do what you wish, and i am always looking forward to the 49 server regardless of things like this; there's always more than one way to gear a char.

Originally Posted by Falkor

and no offense but you contradict yourself by saying you dont want to rehash old ideas, yet you should revisit the past.

I do that a lot, but what I was trying to say was I don't want to make the same weapon over and over again just with scaled stats, so I looked at older weapons that were never revisited. I do think they stopped doing it because of CC issues (like you said before) but that alone shouldn't thwart the concept completely.

I'd also like to look more into the "When hit in combat..." type abilities which will mostly be for Warriors/Pallys (in honor of Hobbs of course)

~Zuty

i like the leggings and shield idea as long as it doesnt make one or so classes OP in wsg (think shaman or pally with run speed increase, or if a warrior decideds its so good he ditches his sta/strength shield specifically for run speed, etc.)