Rogue OH

[Twinkytoes]

Hey guys, I'm making a new twink, and me and a guildie were getting into a fight over a weapon.

Is Battleworn Thrash Blade worth getting for offhand?

Thanks

(LF input by : IAT, and other good ppl at math :P )

[Novascotia]

im good at math

+ chance fur 1nnee extraa swng tht meanz u geeeet moar chancz 2 git fieryy


Problem solved?

[Twinkytoes]

im good at math

+ chance fur 1nnee extraa swng tht meanz u geeeet moar chancz 2 git fieryy


Problem solved?

Can you actually make a valid reply please?

[Trespasser]

Lets see here in order with and without sharpening stones in your offhand:

[With shaperening stones]
1st: Shadowfang
2nd: Battleworn Thrash Blade (only +2 sharpening stone) assuming a shadowfang as mainhand
3rd: Assassin's Blade
4th: Cruel barb
5th: Wingblade
6th: Thief's Blade
7th: Balanced Heartseeker (only +2 sharpening stone)
8th: Skeletal Club
9th: Gutterblade
10th: Tail Spike

[Without shaperening stones]
1st: Shadowfang
2nd: Battleworn Thrash Blade assuming a shadowfang as mainhand
3rd: Cruel Barb
4th: Balanced Heartseeker
5th: Assassin's Blade
6th: Wingblade
7th: Venerable Mass of McGowan
8th: Skeletal Club
9th: Gutterblade
10th: Thief's Blade

Edit: added the part about BWTB assuming shadowfang

[Reshonek]

I've always preferred Wingblade w/15 agi as an offhand stat stick and SF mh w/fiery. Just my opinion, though. I rarely see any rogue with my weapon combo.

[Eliot]

Here is my math it is rather complicated so watch out.

Step 1. Use the search function.

[Twinkytoes]

Lets see here in order with and without sharpening stones in your offhand:

[With shaperening stones]
1st: Shadowfang
2nd: Battleworn Thrash Blade (only +2 sharpening stone) assuming a shadowfang as mainhand
3rd: Assassin's Blade
4th: Cruel barb
5th: Wingblade
6th: Thief's Blade
7th: Balanced Heartseeker (only +2 sharpening stone)
8th: Skeletal Club
9th: Gutterblade
10th: Tail Spike

[Without shaperening stones]
1st: Shadowfang
2nd: Battleworn Thrash Blade assuming a shadowfang as mainhand
3rd: Cruel Barb
4th: Balanced Heartseeker
5th: Assassin's Blade
6th: Wingblade
7th: Venerable Mass of McGowan
8th: Skeletal Club
9th: Gutterblade
10th: Thief's Blade

Edit: added the part about BWTB assuming shadowfang

Hey man! Thanks so much bro

Question for you though, what if CB would be my mainhand, would Battleworn still be BiS? (aside from SF).

[Crilicilyn]

Just go CB/WB w/ 2 shadow oils.

[iaccidentallytwink]

Hey man! Thanks so much bro

Question for you though, what if CB would be my mainhand, would Battleworn still be BiS? (aside from SF).

Seeing as SF in MH makes it 2nd BiS because of the extra MH swing, if the procrate is 5%, you'd do:
BWTB_DPS + (MH_DPS * 0.05) + (MH_PROC_DPS * 0.05).

Assuming SF's proc grants the weapon 1 DPS, and the SF DPS adds ~0.85, I'd say it's more AP dependant, but overall, you'd lose ~.15 DPS compared to an SF in MH (assuming 0 AP, because MH_DPS and BWTB_DPS changes depending on AP.).

[Tonkks]

Twinky if my second shadowfang dissapeared the battleworn thrash would be equipped in 2 seconds. Behind that cruel barb and re enchant back my AB for 15 agil.